We have more access to information than ever before. Whether we're considering a career change, dealing with a challenge at work, or trying to make an important life decision, we can turn to AI and receive suggestions in seconds.
And much of that advice can be useful. But having information and knowing what to do with it are two different things.
So what makes professional expertise valuable when advice is so easy to find?
The Difference Between Advice and Expertise
Imagine someone who is unhappy at work and wondering whether they should change careers. They might ask AI for advice and receive suggestions about updating their resume, identifying their strengths, or exploring new opportunities.
But what if they don't actually want a new career? What if they're exhausted, struggling with their manager, or feeling disconnected from work they once enjoyed?
The advice may be perfectly reasonable, but it may not address what's really happening.
This is where experience and professional judgment become valuable. A skilled coach, consultant, or mentor can ask questions, learn about someone's circumstances, and explore possibilities that may not have been considered.
What Do We Value in Professional Advice?
A 2025 study published in Scientific Reports, Me vs. the Machine? Subjective Evaluations of Human and AI Generated Advice, explored how people respond to advice from humans and AI.
The researchers found that people generally preferred human advice, particularly when discussing personal matters such as relationships and personal development.
This doesn't mean AI advice has no value. It suggests that who we turn to for support matters, especially when the questions are personal.
Why Experience Still Matters
Professional expertise comes from more than education or knowing the right answers. It grows through years of working with people, understanding different situations, and learning that what works for one person may not work for another.
AI can help us gather information, explore ideas, and prepare for important conversations. Experienced professionals can bring another perspective, ask questions we haven't considered, and recognize when a different kind of support might be useful.
As information becomes easier to access, perhaps the value of expertise becomes even clearer.
It's not simply about knowing more. It's about understanding what matters and how that knowledge can help someone move forward.
Written By Lauren Bunton | Posy Co Founder

